Price guide

2025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer 451 PSA 10 value

What a 2025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer 451 PSA 10 sells for on eBay, from 38 completed sales, refreshed Nov 16, 2026. 3 live listings right now.

Typical sold price
$728
median of 38 sales
Typical range
$690–$757
25th to 75th percentile

Underpriced right now

2 more listed at or above the typical price.

Recent sales

DateListingSold forType
2026-11-162025 UPPER DECK SERIES 2 #451 MATTHEW SCHAEFER YOUNG GUNS RC ROOKIE PSA 10$669auction
2026-11-152025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 PSA 10 Islanders$729excellent
2026-11-152025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer 451 PSA 10 Gem Mint Young Guns RC$710auction
2026-11-152025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Hockey Matthew Schaefer #451 Young Guns PSA 10$673auction
2026-11-13Upper Deck 2025-26 Series 2 Young Guns #451 Matthew Schaefer Islanders PSA 10$750auction
2026-11-122025 UPPER DECK SERIES 2 #451 MATTHEW SCHAEFER YOUNG GUNS RC ROOKIE PSA 10$669auction
2026-11-08173304755 Matthew Schaefer 2025 Upper Deck #451 Young Guns RC PSA 10$720auction
2026-11-082025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 - Matthew Schaefer Young Guns RC #451 🔥PSA 10🔥$705auction
2026-11-082025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer PSA 10 Gem Mint Young Guns RC Islanders 451$690auction
2026-11-082025 Upper Deck YOUNG GUNS 451 Matthew Schaefer Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT !$680auction
2026-11-082025 Upper Deck YOUNG GUNS 451 Matthew Schaefer Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT !$670auction
2026-11-072025-26 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Young Guns RC #451 Islanders PSA 10 GEM MINT$680auction
2026-11-062025 UPPER DECK #451 MATTHEW SCHAEFER ROOKIE RC PSA 10$702auction
2026-11-052025 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Young Guns Rookie #451 PSA 10$800excellent
2026-11-052025 Upper Deck YOUNG GUNS 451 Matthew Schaefer Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT !$705auction
2026-11-052025 Upper Deck YOUNG GUNS 451 Matthew Schaefer Rookie RC PSA 10 GEM MINT !$690auction
2026-11-052025 UPPER DECK SERIES 2 #451 MATTHEW SCHAEFER YOUNG GUNS RC ROOKIE PSA 10$678auction
2026-11-032025-26 Upper Deck Matthew Schaefer Young Guns RC #451 Islanders PSA 10 GEM MINT$736auction
2026-11-03MATTHEW SCHAEFER PSA 10 2025-26 UPPER DECK S2 #451 ROOKIE YOUNG GUNS RC 7914$736auction
2026-11-032025-26 Upper Deck Hockey Young Guns #451 Matthew Schaefer RC Rookie PSA 10$730auction

How this value is calculated

GearIQ pulls recent completed eBay listings that match this exact item (same card, same grade), drops anything more than three times above or below the median, and reports the median and the middle half of the range. Best-offer sales show the seller's asking price because eBay hides what the buyer paid, so they only set the number when firm sales are scarce, and then at a 10% discount. Condition, shaft, loft and included extras move the price within the range; check the exact listing before you buy or price your own.

More Upper Deck values